There is such a thing as healthy, mature disagreement. I know there is. I have caught a glimpse of it a few times in my life and it is a beautiful thing. Unfortunately, it is not all that common. It feels like all I am seeing lately is the opposite. Honestly, I am tired of it! I have much more patience with the hateful rhetoric of unbelievers than I do with the childish in fighting of professing Christians. I absolutely hate the passive aggressiveness, the gossiping, the judgmental assumptions, the divisive complaining, the negative critiquing that are so prevalent with disagreements these days among Christian brothers and sisters.
It is simply unrealistic to expect all believers to agree 100% on every theological point this side of heaven. (There are lots of good reasons for this fact.) Many of the great theologians that I respect most disagree with each other! But what I respect about them is the fact that they disagree in a Godly manner. One day we will be brought into complete harmony when it comes to our understanding of everything. Until then we must learn to love each in even when we disagree.
Assuming it is possible, how do we disagree to the glory of God? Here are a just few suggestions that I have learned from very wise people along the way:
- Seek first to understand. Ask questions and then more questions. Finally, ask more questions. Jumping to conclusions and assuming what you do not know is easy to do but very unhelpful.
- Look for common ground. Often times, disagreement is inflated by the sense that there is no common ground. If you can identify the strengths and common ground in opposing viewpoints it will help you shrink down the disagreement to its actual size.
- Discuss, don’t argue. Arguing causes people to build walls and get entrenched. When this happens emotion gets attached to the outcome of the conversation. This prevents any productive conversation.
- Respect each other. It is important to avoid negatively judging a person based on their viewpoint. Respect the fact the other people are just as intellectual, just as committed to God and God’s Word, just as spiritual as you are in spite of the fact that they disagree with you.
- Be Humble. The truth is you may be able to learn something from the person you disagree with. Understand that you are no more perfect than anyone else. You are just as prone to mistakes as anyone else. Humility is key to navigating through disagreement.
- Avoid slander. When you disagree with someone it is important to protect their dignity and reputation. Talk through the disagreement face to face if that is appropriate. When you walk away, don’t speak negatively about the person to others in any way, shape or form. To do so is the opposite of love. If what you are saying about a person will cause others to think badly of them, then do not say it at all.
Here is the bottom line: It is possible for two or more well meaning, God loving, Spirit filled Christians who study God’s Word and seek God’s guidance over a particular secondary theological issue (meaning not primary to our salvation) to disagree. In fact, it is not only possible…it is common. That may be a hard pill to swallow. But it is an important point. If you believe something to the contrary then you will have a hard time giving any grace to those with whom you disagree.
Francis Schaeffer spoke well on this topic in his book, The Mark of A Christian…
“We should never come to such difference with true Christians without regret and without tears. Sounds simple, doesn’t it? Believe me, evangelicals often have not shown it. We rush in, being very, very, pleased, it would seem at times, to find other people’s mistakes. We build ourselves up by tearing other people down. This can never show a real oneness among Christians.”
When Jesus prayed for us to be one (John 17), I don’t believe He was expecting us to agree on every ministry method or theological point. I believe He meant for His followers, who are fully surrendered to His authority, to really love and care for each other. That necessarily means respecting each other through disagreement. We cannot allow disagreement to get in the way of the mission Jesus entrusted to us.The mission is simply too important!
Here is a much better article to read on this subject: When Christians Disagree

